Essays on science, politics, finance, the arts, belief and philosophy, often with an Irish flavour
Friday, October 11, 2013
Thursday, August 2, 2012
Sean Quinn and his place in history
We often like to laud the memory of the giants that bestrode the world stage, such as Napoleon Bonaparte and our own Hugh O’Neill, Earl of Tyrone. The passage of time tends to eliminate the memory of certain of their typical characteristics, like, for example, a tendency to regard the law as something that can be safely ignored until it is rigidly enforced, or to be above serious consideration of the rights and feelings of others. It is the inspiration of their courage and daring that is valued, and whatever contributions they made as a beneficial side effect of their drive and ambition.
The human condition has produced such examples in every generation, so why should we be surprised when they crop up in ours?
In the meantime we have had the benefit of experience and, most significantly, the development of strong systems of government that owe nothing to wealthy individuals or groups, and everything to the mass of the people. These things should, in theory at least, result in regulation, and its enforcement, that would curb the excesses of those who stand out, whether in business or politics.
So why do we not hear more of the one clearly identifiable failure of regulation that led to the Sean Quinn collapse: the totally irrational provision that allowed Contracts For Difference (CFDs) to be immune from the disclosure regulations on the acquisition of company shares? Imagine what the outcome might have been if the ordinary regulatory rules applied to these and other derivatives? Sean Quinn would have been saved from his hubris because he would not have been able to secretly acquire even a fraction of the 25% stake in Anglo Irish Bank he had reached when the bubble burst. He would now remain, albeit somewhat diminished, a national figure of whom we could all be proud as the man who broke the monopolies in cement manufacture and insurance in Ireland, and who brought very significant employment to those regions around the border where it was badly needed.
We would have had, in the modern parlance, a true win-win situation.
Tuesday, June 12, 2012
Can Europe help us fix our public health service?
Long waiting
lists for elective surgery, overworked A & E departments and in-patients
having to be accommodated for long periods on hospital trolleys are the kind of
stories we keep hearing about in relation to the Irish public health service.
Of course these things are unacceptable. But bad as they are, a letter to the
editor of the Irish Times on May 27th 2012, from a GP, has described
a situation that should be made a criminal offence when and if a culprit can be
identified.
The letter
indicates a level of inequality that simply should not exist in any country,
developed or otherwise. It illustrates that ability to pay and not need is the
criterion for hospital treatment here in Ireland . Read it here.
There are
also the inadequate care services in Ireland for those who suffer from
Cystic Fibrosis, despite the fact that we are among the countries with the
highest incidence of this condition. These have been well documented on many
occasions by Orla Tinsley.
The letter above
prompted me to do some research. I was able to locate a report on European
health services that seems detailed and is up-to-date. It’s from a Swedish
benchmarking group called the Health Consumer Powerhouse, it’s called “Euro
Health Consumer Index 2012”, it’s by Arne Björnberg, Ph.D., and it can be
accessed here in .PDF format.
While
inequality of the type highlighted in the letter to the Irish Times as it
relates to Ireland
is not dealt with specifically in the report, it does examine the issues of
waiting lists and the cost of health care on a per capita basis in a total of
34 countries, the majority of them within the EU. In relation to Ireland , two
graphs stand out. The one for waiting list times shows Ireland six
places away from being the worst out of the total of 34. At the best end
of the list lie Switzerland, Belgium, Germany, The Netherlands, Denmark,
France, Austria, Finland and Sweden, with the lowest waiting times. But here’s
the thing: In the graph that shows healthcare spend per capita, Ireland is
right up there near the top along with Denmark, Germany, Belgium, Austria, The Netherlands,
Switzerland, Norway and Luxemburg.
The author of
the report has the following to say about waiting times:
“2.3 Major non-acute operations < 90 days
What is the interval between diagnosis and treatment
for a basket of coronary bypass / PTCA and hip/knee joint? It is difficult to
avoid the observation that for countries, which do have official waiting
time statistics (Ireland , Sweden , UK etc),
this is in itself a not very flattering circumstance. Countries such as Germany , where waiting times tend to vary in the
2 – 3 weeks range, have never felt the urge to produce waiting time data, for principally
the same type of reason that Madrid has less
snow-ploughs than Helsinki ”.
A fair comment, but one is still left with the belief that
pure inequality, as opposed to typical waiting times, is unique to Ireland , at
least within the EU. This is supported by anecdotal evidence from people who
have experienced public healthcare in France , Belgium, The Netherlands and Germany .
Once again one is prompted to ask why there is such an
antipathy to the EU on the part of the radical left wing here in Ireland . If
they were real Socialists they would, surely, embrace Europe
as an exemplar of equality and anti-discrimination, and not as something to be
viewed with suspicion. If they were doing their jobs on behalf of the users of
health services in Ireland
they would be beating a path to Brussels
to highlight the woeful inequalities that have been described here, and getting
all available help to remedy the situation.
Labels:
EU,
European Union,
Health service,
HSE,
Socialists
Monday, May 28, 2012
Vote YES on Thursday
Those who are trying to convince voters that it will have any bearing at all on household charges, septic tank inspection fees, water rates or anything else of that nature are either dangerously delusional or shockingly dishonest.
What is objectively true is that Germany (Bunds [German government bonds] approaching negative yields), Finland, The Netherlands, Austria (unemployment: 4%) have taken control of their finances and are all in favour of the fiscal compact. They simply want other countries to agree to it so that when stimulus measures are put in place for the EU as a whole there will be no free riders. It's hard to blame them for that.
And they're the countries I want to be aligned with in the EU - not the ones that allow UK and US commentators to put us into awful acronyms like PIIGS.
http://www.solarwave.ie/
Labels:
austerity,
EU,
EUROZONE,
fiscal compact,
referendum
Friday, May 25, 2012
What's the Irish left got against the EU?
It would
seem that a large part of the left wing in Ireland
is really, when all is said and done, against the idea of Ireland belonging to the European
Union.
Last week I took the left leaning members of the opposition to task for
not making a lot more of the proposals that have been put forward by the
Germans and the French for a Tobin tax. My point, which I do not seem to have
done enough to get across, was that it was preferable to work with the EU on
measures to raise revenue for economic stimulation instead of simply opposing
fiscal discipline, as they have been doing. After all, a transaction tax on
stocks and bond dealing should be close to the heart of any Socialist, and
money borrowed, even for spending in the hope (and it would be a hope – borrowing
and spending are not of themselves a guarantee of success) of generating
growth, has to be paid back. In any event borrowing, as we know to our costs
since the onset of the Great Financial Crisis, is dodgy under any
circumstances.
Now I read
in the Irish Times that Sinn Fein, in particular, has campaigned against every
EU treaty that has been agreed to by Ireland over the last 25 years. Joe
Higgins has always given the strong impression of a man that only agreed to
become a member of the European Parliament so that he could work to undermine
it from within. A new survey has also found that even a large percentage of
traditional Labour party voters, 41%, intends to vote against the treaty,
despite the strong endorsement of it from all Labour ministers in the current
coalition government.
So what’s
with the Irish left and the EU? In the UK ,
it’s the Conservatives who have the most Euro sceptic members, and the Labour
Party is the one that is committed to taking a full part in Europe .
In France, the newly elected President, Francois Hollande, a Socialist, might
have used rhetoric in his election that will cause him to look for growth
measures to go with the Fiscal Pact, but a Euro sceptic he most certainly is
not. And Angela Merkel and her party, while supporting balanced budgets, are
not afraid to put forward measures that will arouse the ire of capitalism (and
should therefore expect to be embraced by Socialism), a good example being the
aforementioned Tobin tax.
Perhaps
opposition to Europe is a means our Socialists
have decided on in order to differentiate themselves from other parties. This
might have its attractions in providing a quick fix to gain electoral support
in a deep recession, when voters are casting around for anything and everything
that represents the status quo so that it can be punished, but it is not in the
best interest of the country, nor, I would propose, even in the long term electoral
best interests of the politicians concerned.
Labels:
EU,
Euro,
Irish left,
Joe Higgins,
Sinn Fein,
socialism
Thursday, May 10, 2012
Is it right to be absolute?
Pope Benedict XVI and President Barack Obama
President Obama
has come out in favour of same-sex marriage. Good for him.
In an
article in the Irish Times last January (2011) that was inspired by the film
“The King’s Speech”, Fintan O’Toole wrote of the fact that he had once suffered
from a speech impediment. He was interested to hear that some people who had
such a problem also reported that, as children in school, they had been forced
as naturally left-handed people to do everything with their right hands. That also happened to him.
Over many
centuries, left-handedness has been seen by Christianity as being associated
with the devil, and was therefore regarded as something that had to be “cured”,
even if this meant using force and causing severe distress to the child
concerned. Apparently there are many references in the Bible that could be
interpreted as a condemnation of left-handedness, although no prominent church
leader is known to have come out and made anything like the pronouncements
against it that have been made against Gays and Lesbians by, among others,
various popes.
The current
pope is very fond of one particular word. He has condemned what he calls
“relativism” on many occasions. He sees it as something that is taking over the
world and as being closely allied to secularism. As used by the pope, it seems
to imply that, for him and the church, there are a number of basic truths that
can never, ever be challenged - they must remain absolute. This, of course,
immediately causes problems for those in the scientific community because the
scientific method is predicated on the idea of revising or even totally
rejecting anything that does not continue to accord with new evidence as it
becomes available. The pope’s defenders will say he is not concerned with
science (the church was proved so embarrassingly wrong with regard to
scientific pronouncements in the past that it has decided it is better to get
out of the field altogether). However, his condemnation of Gays and Lesbians
and his total rejection of same-sex marriage indicate that he is ignoring the
modern understanding that being gay is just another part of the diversity of
human nature, and is neither good nor bad – it just is.
As for the
idea that the church cannot change its beliefs – this fails to stand up to
scrutiny too. Can you imagine the uproar there would be if a teacher in any
school was found now tying a child’s hand behind his or her back and forcing
them, against their natural inclination, to write with their right hand? Here, at least, is one absolute belief that’s not so absolute any more.
Labels:
Gays and Lesbians,
Left-handedness,
Obama,
Pope Benedict,
same-sex marriage,
sinister,
Stammering
Monday, May 7, 2012
Another reason to vote Yes
Francois Hollande
Socialist Francois Hollande has become the latest president of the Fifth French
Republic . Much has been
made of his apparent attitude to the EU Fiscal Treaty, about which we in Ireland will
have a referendum vote at the end of this month.
At this stage it is impossible
to know how much of M. Hollande’s words represented electioneering rhetoric and
how much will result in solid changes to the treaty, but there is reason to
believe that, while the austerity aspects of the treaty will not change, they
might now be accompanied by measures aimed at stimulating the economy of Europe .
This
represents just one more reason for Ireland to vote Yes in the
referendum. It was always a good idea to confirm our position as members in
good standing of both the EU and the Euro zone, and voting Yes is the means to
achieve that under current circumstances. Now we have an added incentive – as members
that are fully committed to fiscal responsibility, which is what the treaty is
about, we can take full advantage of whatever economic stimulus is brought into
being by the influence of France
under its new leadership.
Labels:
EU,
EUROZONE,
fiscal treaty,
Hollande,
referendum
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)






